4 cards of the same suit.
One card short of a flush (5 cards of the same suit). Its EV (the average return of that hold, in coins for a 1-coin bet) is about 1.28. A suit has 13 cards and you hold 4, so 9 cards complete it. It loses to a high pair and 3 to a royal, but beats a low pair. Example. With 5♥ 5♣ 8♥ J♥ K♥, keep the 4 hearts, not the pair of 5s (about 0.82).