4 cards to a straight that complete only with the one missing middle card.
With 5-6-8-9, only a 7 completes it. Only 4 cards complete it, and its EV (the average return of that hold, in coins for a 1-coin bet) is about 0.34. It even loses to a single high card (a jack or better, about 0.47), so don't hold it unless it contains 3 high cards. Example. With 5♠ 6♦ 8♣ 9♥ K♠, keep the K♠ alone.